Heh, big one for blogers here. This has been in the news alot, but there are a few questions i haven't heard asked, and i think hey are important in relation to America and our first amendment rights(freedom of speech, press, religion, peaceful assembly, petition for redress).
First, a mini history of recent events in this.
-Google and other major web hosting and search companies including Yahoo, MSN, and Microsoft have been aiding the Chinese government track down and censor Chinese citizens who speak out against the government. Those who are caught are often imprisoned for years at a time.
-Advocates for free speech have protested this. Questions have come up including "These are American companies, do the First amendment rights extend to them over seas?"
-Boycotts and protests have sprung up around the US protesting Google, who's motto is/was "Don't Be Evil" following the announcement of their new Chinese version of their search tool.
And now, My Issue:
"Are some of the blogs being censored by these companies for the Chinese Government hosted on servers in the United States?"This is an upsetting question for me. If these web pages are in servers on US soil, then censoring them would be in direct violation of the first amendment. Some would say that the US government is censoring our media already, but that's another blog all together.
I've been unable too find much if any credible and specific data on this, so i don't have much to say about it. If anyone that reads this knows anything, a response would be greatly appreciated.
Discussion Topics:- Should we support the Chinese Censorship of their citizens? Is it essential to their economy that they not be introduced to the ideas of Free Press and Free Speech?
- Do these large companies (Google, Microsoft, Yahoo) need to go to such un-ethical ends to make a profit? Is there a better way to go about this?